# Pull Requests Explained: What to Check When AI Opens One

> A pull request is how AI-written changes get reviewed before they go live. Learn what one shows, what to look at without reading code, and what to ask.

Canonical: https://bridge-terminal.com/atlas/blog/pull-requests-explained-plain-guide-ai-coding/
Last updated: 2026-11-17

Published 17 November 2026 · Plain English · Explainer · 6 min read

## The short version

- A pull request is a proposal to merge a set of changes into a project, so people can discuss and review it before it becomes part of the real product.
- You do not need to read code to use a pull request well: read the description, compare it with what you asked for, look at the size and the checks, and ask what could go wrong.
- A green list of automated checks is evidence, not proof; it only covers what someone wrote a test for.
- On GitHub, administrators can require approving reviews and passing status checks before changes merge into a protected branch, so review cannot be skipped by accident.
- Ask the AI to highlight risks in plain words, as Claude Code's documentation advises, then judge the answer against what you asked for.

A pull request is a proposal to merge a set of changes into a software project. When an AI coding agent finishes a piece of work, it often opens one so that a person, another AI, or an automatic check can look at the changes before they join the real product. If you manage or fund AI-built software, the pull request is the moment where you can still say "wait".

You do not need to read code to use it well. This guide explains what a pull request contains, what a non-coder can check, and which questions to ask.

## What is a pull request?

Think of a shared document with tracked changes. Nobody edits the master copy directly. Instead, someone makes their edits on a separate copy, and then asks: "Please look at what I changed, and add it to the master if you agree."

That is a pull request. In software, the separate copy is called a **branch**, and the master copy is usually called **main**. [GitHub's documentation](https://docs.github.com/en/pull-requests/collaborating-with-pull-requests/proposing-changes-to-your-work-with-pull-requests/about-pull-requests) describes pull requests as proposals to merge code changes into a project, and says they let teams discuss and review changes before merging. "Merging" simply means adding the changes to main.

## What does a pull request show you?

On GitHub, a pull request is split into several tabs, each showing a different view of the same change:

- **Conversation:** the description, timeline, comments and reviews.
- **Commits:** how the branch changed over time, step by step.
- **Files changed:** the exact differences, line by line. This is the part engineers read closely.
- **Checks:** automated tests, builds and other validations.
- **Findings:** automated code review results, such as code scanning alerts (warnings about possible security problems).

As a non-coder, you will spend most of your time in two places: the **Conversation** (what is this change, and why?) and the **Checks** (did the automatic tests pass?). The line-by-line view is for someone who writes code, or for an AI reviewer you have asked to read it.

## Why do pull requests matter more with AI agents?

An AI agent can produce a lot of changes quickly. That is useful, but it also means a lot of changes can arrive that nobody has understood. The pull request creates a pause. It is a natural place to ask whether the work matches your request, whether it was tested, and whether it touches something sensitive such as sign-in or payments.

Claude Code, Anthropic's coding agent, can open pull requests when asked. Its [documentation](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/common-workflows) says you can ask it directly ("create a pr for my changes"), and adds a tip: review the generated pull request before submitting, and ask Claude to highlight potential risks or considerations. That is good advice for anyone, coder or not.

## What can a non-coder check in a pull request?

You can get real value from a five-minute look. Try this order.

### 1. Read the description

A good description says what changed, why, and how it was tested. A bad one says "various fixes". If it is vague, ask the agent to rewrite it in plain words.

### 2. Compare it with what you asked for

Open your original request next to the description. Is everything you asked for there? Is there anything you did not ask for? Extra changes are a common source of surprises, because every extra change is something else that can break.

### 3. Look at the size

A small pull request is easier to judge than a huge one. If a "small fix" touches dozens of files, ask why. You do not need to understand the files. The number is the signal.

### 4. Look at the checks

The Checks tab shows whether automated tests and builds passed. Green is good news. Red means something failed and the change should not merge yet. Be careful with green, though: it only means the tests that exist passed. If nobody wrote a test for the thing you care about, a green tick says nothing about it.

### 5. Ask for the risks in plain words

Ask: "What could go wrong with this change, who would notice first, and how would we undo it?" If the agent cannot answer, that tells you something. The undo part matters: before anything goes live, you want to know the way back.

## What are draft pull requests?

A draft is a pull request marked as work in progress. GitHub's documentation says drafts are useful for sharing work in progress without formally requesting reviews, and that draft pull requests cannot be merged. When the author is ready, they mark it ready for review. This helps: if an agent opens a draft, you know it is not asking for a decision yet.

## How do teams stop changes skipping review?

A rule that says "please review first" only works if the system enforces it. On GitHub, this is done with protected branches. [GitHub's documentation on protected branches](https://docs.github.com/en/repositories/configuring-branches-and-merges-in-your-repository/managing-protected-branches/about-protected-branches) says administrators can require:

- that every pull request gets a set number of approving reviews before it merges;
- that required status checks pass before collaborators can change the branch;
- and by default, GitHub blocks force pushes on protected branches. A force push is a way of overwriting a project's history.

If your project is on GitHub and an AI agent has access to it, ask your engineer or agency one question: "Is main protected, and what does it require?" If the answer is "no", nothing in the system forces a review step, and the process depends on everyone remembering to follow it. That is a cheap risk to remove.

## Who should approve a pull request when AI wrote it?

Approval should come from someone who is accountable and understands the change well enough to say yes. That can be:

- an engineer on your team;
- a separate AI reviewer, as long as a person decides what to do with its findings;
- you, for questions only you can answer, such as "is this what I meant?"

What you should avoid is the same agent writing the change, judging it and approving it. A second pair of eyes, human or AI, is the point of the process.

## How does Atlas handle this?

Atlas is a software team made of AI engineers, built on Claude Code. It does not work through GitHub pull requests as described above, but it follows similar ideas in its own way. Each engineer works in its own copy of the code. Every build is reviewed as it finishes and comes back either releasable or with fix tasks filed to the engineer who built it. Finished branches go through what Atlas calls the landing train, which merges up to six of them and runs the project's own checks once on the result. If a batch fails, it is split until the branch that broke it is found. Main's history is never rewritten.

What Atlas does not do today is turn each landed batch into a plain-English summary of what changed for a non-coder. That is coming to Atlas, built in, so it needs no setup. Until then, you can use the habits in this guide: compare what was delivered with what you asked for, ask PA, the project assistant, to explain the change and its risks in plain words, and check which tests ran. You can read more on the [Atlas home page](https://bridge-terminal.com/atlas/).

## A short checklist

Before you say yes to a change:

1. Does the description match what I asked for?
2. Is the size what I expected?
3. Did the checks pass, and do they cover what I care about?
4. Has someone other than the author reviewed it?
5. Do I know how we would undo it?

## Conclusion

A pull request is a pause point, and you control how much you get out of it. You do not need to read the code. Read the description, compare it with your request, check the size and the checks, and ask for the risks in plain words. Then make sure the project is set up so that the review step cannot be skipped.

## Questions people ask

### What is a pull request in simple terms?

It is a proposal to add a set of changes to the main version of a project. It lets people discuss and review the changes before they are merged.

### Do I need to read code to review a pull request?

No. You can read the description, compare it with your request, look at how big the change is, check whether the automated checks passed, and ask the author to explain the risks in plain words.

### Does a green checkmark mean a pull request is safe?

No. It means the automated tests and builds that exist passed. If nobody wrote a test for the thing you care about, a green result says nothing about it.

### How do I stop an AI agent merging changes without review?

On GitHub, administrators can protect the main branch so that merging requires a set number of approving reviews and passing status checks. Ask your engineer whether main is protected, and what it requires.

### What is a draft pull request?

It is a pull request marked as work in progress. According to GitHub, drafts let you share work without formally requesting reviews, and they cannot be merged until marked ready.

## About Atlas: Review before changes join the real product

Atlas engineers each work in their own copy of the code, every build is reviewed as it finishes, and the landing train merges up to six branches and runs the project's own checks once. A plain-English summary of each landed batch is coming to Atlas, built in, with no setup. Until then, ask PA to explain a change and its risks. — https://bridge-terminal.com/atlas/

## Sources

- [About pull requests - GitHub Docs](https://docs.github.com/en/pull-requests/collaborating-with-pull-requests/proposing-changes-to-your-work-with-pull-requests/about-pull-requests)
- [About protected branches - GitHub Docs](https://docs.github.com/en/repositories/configuring-branches-and-merges-in-your-repository/managing-protected-branches/about-protected-branches)
- [Common workflows - Claude Code Docs](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/common-workflows)

_Researched and drafted with Claude, then checked against the sources above. Atlas is an independent product, not affiliated with Anthropic or OpenAI._

## Related

- [Flaky Tests: Meaning, Causes and Fixes for AI-Built Apps](https://bridge-terminal.com/atlas/blog/what-is-a-flaky-test-plain-guide/)
- [AI Code Review with Claude Code: What It Catches and Misses](https://bridge-terminal.com/atlas/blog/ai-code-review-claude-code-setup/)
- [Database Backups Before an AI Release: What to Ask](https://bridge-terminal.com/atlas/blog/database-backups-before-ai-release-what-to-ask/)
